Overcoming Polanyi’s Double Movement

Resolving the conflict between market demands and human needs

Date added: November 10, 2026
*** Not enough feedback data received to date. ***

​← Why Sign? The Five Key Questions That Can Help You Decide​

Preamble

More than 80 years ago, political economist Karl Polanyi warned in The Great Transformation that subordinating society to market principles of competition and self-interest would inevitably provoke a protective response.

He called this the double movement.

As market forces undermine social stability and human welfare, society demands protection through government intervention, regulation, social services and other measures designed to mitigate the damage.

This creates an ongoing tension between the economic demands of the market and the human needs of society.

Today, this tension is particularly evident in the growing demand for healthcare, disability support, aged care and other essential social services.

These services are fundamental to human wellbeing. Yet their growing costs, combined with relatively low measured productivity growth in many labour-intensive services, place increasing pressure on government budgets and the wider economy.

Where additional expenditure outpaces the economy's capacity to deliver goods and services, it can contribute to inflationary pressures, prompting higher interest rates and creating further economic hardship.

The result can be a recurring cycle in which efforts to protect society generate new economic pressures, requiring further intervention.

What if we could break this cycle by changing the relationship between society and the market itself?

The proposed Global Social Capital Fund offers a fundamentally different approach.

Rather than relying primarily on taxation, government spending and regulation to address the social consequences of market activity, the GSCF would provide a mechanism for integrating investment in social capital more directly into the economy.

The Fund would be financed through a Social Capital Levy included in PByT Group Membership fees, with consumer choice creating a commercial incentive for businesses to participate.

This would provide a new source of funding for charities and not-for-profit organisations, helping strengthen the social foundations upon which a healthy economy depends.

The objective is to change the economic incentives themselves — making investment in social capital a commercial advantage rather than a discretionary expense.

An initial Australian trial will test whether this approach can encourage widespread business participation and establish a sustainable new source of funding for the not-for-profit sector.

This raises the possibility of addressing the underlying tension identified by Polanyi — not simply by protecting society from the consequences of market activity, but by making the wellbeing of society an integral consideration in economic activity.

Question:

Instead of continually compensating for the social consequences of market activity, we can introduce market incentives so that economic success increasingly contributes to social wellbeing, rather than undermining it?

​(Agree/ Disagree →)

***

​← Why Sign? The Five Key Questions That Can Help You Decide​

Click to give Feedback

Please log in or join, in order to view or give feedback.

Connect

Feedback Analysis

*** Not enough feedback data received to date ***

Feedback ... (No Comments)

Please log in or join, in order to view or give feedback.